Fayette County, Illinois Fishing Lakes

Fayette County, Illinois is home to a total of 25 lakes, arranged alphabetically in the list below. If you are considering fishing in Fayette County, Illinois, get more information by clicking on any lake in the list below. Help others by telling us what you know about these county lakes.

Find a Lake

Looking for a particular lake? Search our site!
Bails Timberline Lake (Altamont West area)
Brush Lake (Hagarstown area)
Fish Lake (Hagarstown area)
Gatch Lake (Brownstown area)
Goose Pond (Wildcat Lake area)
Grass Pond (Wildcat Lake area)
Half Mile Pond (Wildcat Lake area)
Hem Pond (Wildcat Lake area)
Hook Lake (Vandalia area)
Horseshoe Lake (Vandalia area)
Illinois No Name Number 2040 Reservoir (Patoka area)
Lake Nellie (Altamont West area)
Lake Timberland (Altamont West area)
Old River Lake (historical) (Wildcat Lake area)
Oliver Reece Pond (Brownstown area)
Otter Pond (Wildcat Lake area)
Ramsey Lake (Ramsey Lake area)
Saint Elmo Old City Reservoir (Altamont West area)
Saint Peter Sportsman Lake (Brownstown area)
Soper Lake (historical) (Wildcat Lake area)
Stanbery Lake (Vandalia area)
Suttons Pond (Hagarstown area)
Vandalia Lake (Hagarstown area)
Vandalia Municipal Reservoir (Vera area)
Wildcat Lake (Wildcat Lake area)