Cayuga County, New York Fishing Lakes

Cayuga County, New York is home to a total of 14 lakes, arranged alphabetically in the list below. If you are considering fishing in Cayuga County, New York, get more information by clicking on any lake in the list below. Help others by telling us what you know about these county lakes.

Find a Lake

Looking for a particular lake? Search our site!
Auburn Reservoir (Auburn area)
Cayuga Lake (Sheldrake area)
Cross Lake (Lysander area)
Duck Lake (Victory area)
Juniper Pond (Fair Haven area)
Lake Como (Sempronius area)
Mud Pond (Cato area)
Mud Pond (Victory area)
Otter Lake (Cato area)
Owasco Lake (Auburn area)
Parker Pond (Cato area)
Slayton Pond (Montezuma area)
Stark Pond (Weedsport area)
The Pond (Fair Haven area)
Woods Mill Pond (historical) (Scipio Center area)