Herkimer County, New York Fishing Lakes

Atwood Lake (Ohio area)
Baby Lake (Morehouseville area)
Bald Mountain Pond (Old Forge area)
Bear Lake (McKeever area)
Bear Pond (Beaver River area)
Bear Pond (Stillwater area)
Beaver Pond (Thendara area)
Beaverdam Pond (Beaver River area)
Beaverdam Pond (Limekiln Lake area)
Big Burnt Lake (Beaver River area)
Big Chief Pond (Eagle Bay area)
Big Diamond Pond (Big Moose area)
Big Five (Five Ponds area)
Big Moose Lake (Eagle Bay area)
Big Otter Lake (Thendara area)
Big Shallow (Five Ponds area)
Bisby Lakes (Bisby Lakes area)
Black Creek Lake (Black Creek Lake area)
Black Creek Reservoir (Ohio area)
Blackfoot Pond (Thendara area)
Bloodsucker Pond (McKeever area)
Bloodsucker Pond (Thendara area)
Blue Pond (Stillwater Mountain area)
Boyer Lake (Morehouse Lake area)
Brewer Lake (McKeever area)
Brindle Pond (Stillwater area)
Bubb Lake (Eagle Bay area)
Buck Pond (Big Moose area)
Buck Pond (McKeever area)
Buck Pond (Nehasane Lake area)
Buck Pond (Stillwater area)
Bullhead Pond (Black Creek Lake area)
Burp Lake (Black Creek Lake area)
Butler Lake (Panther Lake area)
Cage Lake (Oswegatchie SE area)
Canachagala Lake (Bisby Lakes area)
Cary Lake (Big Moose area)
Cedar Lake (West Winfield area)
Cedar Pond (Thendara area)
Chamber Lake (Bisby Lakes area)
Chub Pond (McKeever area)
Clear Lake (Beaver River area)
Clear Pond (Big Moose area)
Cliff Pond (Limekiln Lake area)
Combs Lake (Bisby Lakes area)
Cotton Lake (Black Creek Lake area)
Covey Pond (Beaver River area)
Cracker Pond (Five Ponds area)
Cranberry Lake (Jerseyfield Lake area)
Cranberry Pond (Big Moose area)
Crooked Lake (Beaver River area)
Cropsey Pond (Stillwater area)
Cross Pond (Limekiln Lake area)
Curtis Lake (Ohio area)
Dart Lake (Eagle Bay area)
Deep Lake (North Wilmurt area)
Deer Pond (Stillwater area)
Deer Pond (Wolf Mountain area)
Desert Pond (Oswegatchie SW area)
Diana Pond (Stillwater area)
Dismal Pond (Beaver River area)
Doe Pond (Big Moose area)
Doe Pond (Limekiln Lake area)
Dolgeville Reservoir (Salisbury area)
Duck Pond (Stillwater area)
Dwight Pond (Old Forge area)
East Canada Lake (Oppenheim area)
East Pond (Eagle Bay area)
East Pond (Old Forge area)
East Pond (Thendara area)
Elbow Pond (Beaver River area)
Emerald Lake (Oswegatchie SE area)
Evergreen Lake (Stillwater area)
Falls Lake (Beaver River area)
Fifth Creek Pond (Stillwater Mountain area)
Figert Lake (Ohio area)
Finches Pond (Ohio area)
First Lake (Bisby Lakes area)
First Lake (Old Forge area)
Five Ponds (Five Ponds area)
Fly Pond (Old Forge area)
Fourth Lake (Bisby Lakes area)
Fourth Lake (Limekiln Lake area)
Fox Pond (Limekiln Lake area)
Fulton Chain Lakes (Limekiln Lake area)
Gal Pond (Five Ponds area)
Gibbs Lake (Thendara area)
Ginger Pond (Stillwater area)
Goose Pond (Big Moose area)
Gooseneck Lake (Honnedaga Lake area)
Graffenburg Reservoir (Utica East area)
Grass Pond (Stillwater Mountain area)
Grass Pond (Thendara area)
Grassy Pond (Five Ponds area)
Grassy Pond (Oswegatchie SE area)
Gray Lake (Old Forge area)
Green Lake (Old Forge area)
Green Pond (Stillwater area)
Green Pond (Stillwater Mountain area)
Gregg Lake (Stillwater area)
Gull Lake (Five Ponds area)
Gull Lake (McKeever area)
Gull Lake (Thendara area)
Half Moon Pond (Thendara area)
Hall Pond (Limekiln Lake area)
Hardscrabble Lake (Bisby Lakes area)
Harry Ponds (Limekiln Lake area)
Hawk Pond (Beaver River area)
Herkimer Reservoir (Hinckley area)
Hidden Lake (Beaver River area)
Higby Twin Ponds (Beaver River area)
Hinckley Reservoir (Hinckley area)
Hitchcock Lake (Stillwater Mountain area)
Hitchcock Pond (Stillwater Mountain area)
Hitchins Pond (Five Ponds area)
Hitchock Pond (Stillwater Mountain area)
Hog Pond (Stillwater area)
Honnedaga Lake (Honnedaga Lake area)
Horn Lake (Honnedaga Lake area)
Horseshoe Pond (Old Forge area)
Huckleberry Pond (Beaver River area)
Hyde Pond (Five Ponds area)
Ilion Reservoir Number One (Millers Mills area)
Ilion Reservoir Number Three (Millers Mills area)
Ilion Reservoir Number Two (Millers Mills area)
Independence Lake (Big Moose area)
Jackson Pond (Stillwater area)
Jakes Pond (Soft Maple Reservoir area)
Jenkins Pond (Wolf Mountain area)
Jerseyfield Lake (Jerseyfield Lake area)
Jock Pond (Eagle Bay area)
Johns Pond (Limekiln Lake area)
Kelley Pond (Oswegatchie SE area)
Kettle Pond (Limekiln Lake area)
Kibby Pond (West Winfield area)
Klondike Reservoir (Salisbury area)
Kyser Lake (Little Falls area)
Lake Charlotte (Hinckley area)
Lake Easka (Thendara area)
Lake Gay (Hinckley area)
Lake Kan-ac-to (Big Moose area)
Lake Margarite (Hinckley area)
Lake Rondaxe (Big Moose area)
Lake Tamarack (Ohio area)
Lake Te-jec-na (Big Moose area)
Lake Tekeni (Thendara area)
Lennon Ponds (Stillwater Mountain area)
Lily Lake (Bisby Lakes area)
Lilypad Ponds (Eagle Bay area)
Little Birch Pond (Big Moose area)
Little Chief Pond (Eagle Bay area)
Little Crooked Lake (Five Ponds area)
Little Deer Lake (Honnedaga Lake area)
Little Deer Lake (Ohio area)
Little Diamond Pond (Big Moose area)
Little Duck Pond (Five Ponds area)
Little Five (Five Ponds area)
Little Independence Pond (Big Moose area)
Little Metcalf Lake (Morehouse Lake area)
Little Moose Lake (Old Forge area)
Little Mudhole (Oswegatchie SW area)
Little Rock Pond (Beaver River area)
Little Rock Pond (Big Moose area)
Little Safford Lake (Big Moose area)
Little Salmon Lake (Morehouseville area)
Little Shallow (Five Ponds area)
Little Simon Pond (Thendara area)
Little Woodhull Lake (Bisby Lakes area)
Lone Duck Pond (Five Ponds area)
Loon Hollows Pond (Stillwater area)
Loon Lake (Beaver River area)
Lost Island Pond (Beaver River area)
Lost Pond (Big Moose area)
Lost Pond (Oswegatchie SW area)
Lower Beech Ridge Pond (Beaver River area)
Lower South Pond (Stillwater area)
Lyon Lake (Stillwater area)
Mad Tom Lake (Black Creek Lake area)
Maple Lake (North Wilmurt area)
Massawepie Pond (Oswegatchie SE area)
Merriam Lake (Eagle Bay area)
Middle Branch Lake (Thendara area)
Middle Settlement Lake (Thendara area)
Middle South Pond (Stillwater area)
Mill Creek Lake (Black Creek Lake area)
Mink Lake (North Wilmurt area)
Mirror Lake (Herkimer area)
Monument Lake (Honnedaga Lake area)
Moose Pond (Stillwater Mountain area)
Moshier Ponds (Stillwater area)
Moshier Reservoir (Stillwater area)
Moss Lake (Eagle Bay area)
Mountain Lake (Honnedaga Lake area)
Mountain Pond (Big Moose area)
Mountain Pond (Old Forge area)
Mounts Creek Lake (Jerseyfield Lake area)
Mud Lake (Beaver River area)
Mud Lake (Jerseyfield Lake area)
Mud Lake (Jordanville area)
Mud Pond (Beaver River area)
Mud Pond (Bisby Lakes area)
Mud Pond (Limekiln Lake area)
Mud Pond (Morehouse Lake area)
Muir Pond (Five Ponds area)
Muskrat Pond (Stillwater area)
Negro Lake (Nehasane Lake area)
Nelson Lake (Thendara area)
Nicks Lake (Old Forge area)
Nicks Pond (Wolf Mountain area)
Norridgewock Lake (Beaver River area)
North Branch (Jerseyfield Lake area)
North Branch Lake (Black Creek Lake area)
North Lake (Bisby Lakes area)
North Pond (Thendara area)
Okara Lakes (Thendara area)
Oswego Pond (Big Moose area)
Oven Lake (Five Ponds area)
Panther Lake (Old Forge area)
Partlow Milldam (Wolf Mountain area)
Peaked Mountain Lake (Stillwater area)
Pepperbox Pond (Stillwater area)
Pico Lake (Limekiln Lake area)
Pocket Ponds (Big Moose area)
Quiver Pond (Limekiln Lake area)
Raven Lake (Stillwater area)
Razorback Pond (Big Moose area)
Reeds Pond (North Wilmurt area)
Riley Ponds (Five Ponds area)
Rock Lake (Nehasane Lake area)
Rock Lake (Oswegatchie SE area)
Rock Pond (Old Forge area)
Rock Pond (Thendara area)
Round Pond (Limekiln Lake area)
Round Pond (Old Forge area)
Safford Pond (Big Moose area)
Salmon Lake (Beaver River area)
Sand Lake (Bisby Lakes area)
Sand Lake (Oswegatchie SE area)
Second Lake (Bisby Lakes area)
Second Lake (Old Forge area)
Shallow Pond (Stillwater area)
Silver Dollar Pond (Big Moose area)
Silver Lake (Big Moose area)
Sis Lake (Eagle Bay area)
Sitz Pond (Beaver River area)
Slim Pond (Stillwater area)
Snake Pond (Big Moose area)
Snyder Lake (Honnedaga Lake area)
Snyders Pond (Ohio area)
Soda Pond (Stillwater area)
South Lake (Bisby Lakes area)
South Pond (Big Moose area)
Spectacle Lake (Ohio area)
Spring Pond (Soft Maple Reservoir area)
Spruce Lake (Salisbury area)
Squash Pond (Big Moose area)
Squirrel Ponds (McKeever area)
Stearns Mudhole (Honnedaga Lake area)
Stillwater Reservoir (Stillwater area)
Stink Lake (Limekiln Lake area)
Stone Dam Lake (North Wilmurt area)
Streeter Fishpond (Five Ponds area)
Sucker Pond (Morehouseville area)
Summit Pond (Beaver River area)
Sunday Lake (Stillwater Mountain area)
Sunshine Pond (Stillwater area)
Surprise Pond (Eagle Bay area)
Swan Lake (Black Creek Lake area)
Sylvan Ponds (Bisby Lakes area)
Tamarack Lake (Thendara area)
Taylor Pond (Limekiln Lake area)
Third Lake (Bisby Lakes area)
Third Lake (Old Forge area)
Thirsty Pond (Big Moose area)
Threemile Vly (Morehouseville area)
Tied Lake (Stillwater area)
Toad Pond (Five Ponds area)
Tom Kettle Lake (Ohio area)
Townsend Pond (Eagle Bay area)
Trout Pond (Beaver River area)
Twin Lakes (Black Creek Lake area)
Twin Lakes (Honnedaga Lake area)
Twin Pond (Old Forge area)
Twin Ponds (Stillwater area)
Twitchell Lake (Big Moose area)
Unadilla Lake (Millers Mills area)
Upper Beech Ridge Pond (Beaver River area)
Upper South Pond (Stillwater area)
Walker Lake (Beaver River area)
Washbowl (Five Ponds area)
Weatherby Pond (Richfield Springs area)
Weaver Lake (Richfield Springs area)
West Lake (Big Moose area)
West Pond (Big Moose area)
West Pond (Five Ponds area)
West Pond (Thendara area)
Wheeler Pond (Old Forge area)
Wheeler Pond (Thendara area)
Wheelock Pond (Millers Mills area)
Wheelock Pond (West Winfield area)
White Lead Lake (Black Creek Lake area)
Why Pond (Limekiln Lake area)
Wilder Pond (Nehasane Lake area)
Willys Lake (Beaver River area)
Windfall Pond (Eagle Bay area)
Witchhopple Lake (Beaver River area)
Wolf Pond (Five Ponds area)
Wolf Pond (Oswegatchie SE area)
Woodhull Lake (Bisby Lakes area)
Woods Lake (Big Moose area)
Young Lake (Richfield Springs area)